Week 11 Reflection

What I learned

Last week I finished off my data collection, so I have been able to look at the data a little bit. It turns out the students did enjoy the simulations, but they felt that they were not a replacement for lab work. This was my thought all along, so their support of this thinking was very positive. Most simulations they did were received well, except by one student. This student was very negative towards the simulations where the other students were not. After reviewing this data I feel as if I need to introduce more simulations (a greater variety from several different companies). I could see how having one site could skew data in this way. If I had done all of the simulations from one site I could have obtained a completely different opinion.

What the data tells me

I discovered that the students:

  • Were highly engaged when exploring science-based computer simulations.
  • Interacted appropriately with students to share discoveries.
  • Enjoyed the simulations.
  • Thought that simulations were educational and beneficial to introducing lab experiments and/or equipment.

Applying my data to the real world

Then in applying this research to my current position, I am still adamant that I can’t use simulations in the gym. I only see my students for 45 minutes once a week. It is not enough time to do simulations with them. If I had them daily that would be different, I would then have the time and opportunities to introduce simulation games on nutrition and health or differing muscles and why it is important to stretch and warm up our bodies. This could be something that middle school and high school teachers could do. I would like to share my findings with other PE teachers. I meet with the other elementary PE teachers once a month. I can share these ideas with them there. I was also thinking of sharing my data with the teachers in my building during a staff meeting or a teacher inservice day. This information could benefit the use of simulations when teaching science in school. Scott also mentioned how I could share it with others using Google Docs, Moodle, or even Edmodo.

Impact of this week’s interactions

I was reminded of the importance of rubrics. I don’t tend to use rubrics in PE or in my reading intervention groups, though I do a lot of observation data collection. This would be a great way to justify the grades students have been receiving, and if I keep it very simple it shouldn’t be that difficult to create. I love reading other posts and responses to my own posts. They are very beneficial in reminding me about things, or giving me new ideas to build on. Just like the Twitter session this week, we were able to read posts from everyone on these really cool walls that we can go back to at any time and view. It was great to read what others were doing and thinking.


2 thoughts on “Week 11 Reflection

  1. You wrote: “It turns out the students did enjoy the simulations, but they felt that they were not a replacement for lab work.” Did you collect the responses on why they felt this way? The must enjoy their lab work 🙂 Or where the simulation not “real” enough for them? For schools that have limited lab space or tools, using simulations to supplement might be a good option. For example, a school I worked at two science teachers had to share a lab room, so the teachers had to work together to figure out who would be in the lab and when. Simulations might help alleviate the problem of both teachers wanting to use the lab.


  2. i agree, if you don’t have the resources then this would be a great way to get around them. The kids felt that labs are inportant and that the hands on work they do with labs is an experience that they felt needed to actually be done. The simulations were fun but then they wanted to actually do the activity to prove that it really did work and that the simulation wasn’t just like a cartoon, where it may or may not be true.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s